background

Cyclist and motorist equally liable for accident

Get the help you deserve

The Court in the matter of Chu v Russell has found a cyclist and a motorist to be equally liable for serious injuries sustained by the cyclist in a motor vehicle accident. The cyclist’s compensation was therefore halved.

The main facts were:

  • The motorist was travelling at nearly 100 km per hour on a country road (the speed limit was 100 km per hour) when he first saw the cyclist.
  • When the motorist was about 50 metres in front of the cyclist he reduced his speed to about 90-93 km per hour.
  • As the motorist approached the cyclist, the cyclist suddenly turned right in front of him.

The Court held that the cyclist’s conduct "involved a gross departure from the standard of care required of a reasonable cyclist". The court also held that while the cyclist created a dangerous situation, this factor was more or less cancelled out by the "inequality" between the car and the bicycle in relation to size, weight, speed and manoeuvrability, and by the plaintiff’s consequent vulnerability as a cyclist. Ultimately the Court held that ordinary and reasonable drivers slow down when they are approaching cyclists on country roads, and take extra care when passing them. The motorist therefore breached the duty he owed to the cyclist.

The case stands as a reminder for all motorists to be extra vigilant when passing cyclists on roads at high speeds. Equally, cyclists need to be vigilant as invariably the cyclist will come off "second best" in a collision.

If you have been injured on the road, Accident Legal provides 24/7 direct access to our senior lawyers and a customised approach to each claim to ensure our clients receive maximum compensation. No win no fee.

We’d love to help you or someone you know who has been injured in a road accident. To find out more about Accident Legal, head to our About Us page.

Contact us 24/7 on FREE CALL 1800 745 745 or e-mail info@accidentlegal.com.au

Contact Accident Legal

Brisbane

Level 2/167 Eagle Street
Brisbane QLD 4000

Logan

Level 1/3972 Pacific
Highway Loganholme
QLD 4129

Gold Coast

Suite 30610, Level 6
Southport Central
9 Lawson Street, Southport
QLD 4215

Noosa

Noosa Civic Commercial
28 Eenie Creek Road
Noosaville QLD 4566

Maroochydore

Suite 101, Tower 2 Kon Tiki
Business Centre
55 Plaza Parade
Maroochydore QLD 4558

Read our latest news

Are you distracted by your phone? Walking distracted could soon be illegal


Are you watching where you are walking? Or are you distracted by your phone? It’s time to put your phone away and be engaged with your surroundings because pedestrians walking whil [..]

Are you covered when riding in an Uber?


Since Uber launched many people have claimed that it is unsafe and uninsured. So are you covered if an accident were to occur in an Uber? In short, yes, anyone who is a passenger [..]

Cannabis indulging surfer awarded over $400,000 in damages


The Queensland Supreme Court on 11 March 2016 awarded Mr Schneider $447,969.94 in damages. Mr Schneider was injured in a motorcycle accident on 9 March 2010. Mr Schneider suffered [..]

Claimant’s life goes from rags to riches


A man who became homeless after a motor vehicle accident was awarded $1.28 million. In Martin v Andrews [2016] QSC 20 the Queensland Supreme Court awarded Mr Martin, who sustained [..]

Read more

Book your 100% free, no-obligation expert case review here