Discovery Disputes: Getting the Documents You Need
In this procedural episode of P.I. Case Note, we examine the Queensland Supreme Court decision in Sinclair v Coles Supermarkets [2024] QSC 175, which addresses requests for information and documents under section 27 of the Personal Injuries Proceedings Act 2002 (Qld). The case demonstrates the ongoing battles between plaintiffs seeking comprehensive discovery and defendants attempting to limit their disclosure obligations.
The court’s analysis provides practical guidance on what constitutes reasonable requests for information in personal injury proceedings and when courts will compel defendants to provide additional documentation. This decision is particularly relevant for cases where defendants control critical evidence about safety systems, incident reports, and prior similar occurrences. The judgment helps define the boundaries of pre-litigation disclosure requirements.
Listen for our comprehensive analysis of this discovery decision. If you’re pursuing a personal injury claim against a major corporation, getting access to the right documents can make or break your case. Contact accident legal for a free consultation—we know how to compel proper disclosure from even the most reluctant defendants.